Grammar and punctuation.
Make corrections as you go along. Help your partner. Mark the draft up as you see fit.
Check topic sentences:
Are they argumentative? They should not be presentations of evidence. Instead, they should explicitly state what the paragraph is about to establish. Rewrite any topic sentences that are not correctly drafted.
Topic sentences should connect. That is, they should logically succeed each other in an understandable way. Copy and paste each topic sentence into a separate paragraph, so that each topic sentence follows in order. If the topic sentences do not connect logically in some sensible way, then make a suggestion by rewriting the sentences so that they have logical connections. This does not mean that you should simply add transitional tags — “next,” or “having said that,” or something similar. Try to find connecting logic. If they do connect, then paraphrase in one or two sentences the logic in those connections — outline briefly how the logic is working.
Now ensure that each paragraph has academic evidence.
Academic evidence should be relevant. The relevance should be clearly understood and explained. If there’s no analysis that ties the evidence to the paragraph’s point, then write one or two sentences that suggest how the analysis might work.
Three-step method. Make sure in every instance that the three-step method is being used to introduce and analyze evidence in every paragraph. The steps should be clear. If the three-step method is not being used, or is being used but could be improved, make a one- or two-sentence suggestion for improvement.
Overall structure.
Be sure that each overall paragraph follows the Body Paragraph Form (copied below). Make notes about how the paragraph is deviating from the form if this is the case. Remember that each paragraph incorporates BOTH patterns: the Paragraph Introductory Pattern and the Textual Analysis pattern.
Logic.
Finally, and most importantly, does the paragraph make sense? Can you track what the paragraph is saying and why? Be clear about what the author is asserting. Do so in this way:
Write a three-sentence paraphrase of the paragraph’s point. Include the main idea and a brief outline of the paragraph’s evidence and analysis. This should be a distillation of an eight- to ten-sentence paragraph that still captures the main idea and the paragraph’s approach to analysis.
Copy the peer review into a Google Document and paste the URL, with editing privileges, into this assignment.
Finally, remember that the point here is to use these ideas for your own work. Remember to transfer the knowledge — this must be intentional.
BODY PARAGRAPH FORM
This first pattern is the Paragraph Introductory Pattern. You should use this only once per paragraph.
Topic sentence — one (1) sentence. This should be a clear, unambiguous claim about what the paragraph is going to demonstrate. Resist introducing evidence in the topic sentence. Instead, focus on making a claim that requires proof.
Explicitly state now how you’re going to prove the topic sentence’s claim. This might require more than one (1) or two (2) sentences.
Next, we’ll again use the Textual Analysis Pattern for each of the two following paragraphs. But we’ll add a sentence to the top of the paragraph.
Then, introduce the scene you’re about to discuss. Do this with two (2) sentences:
The first sentence should somewhat broadly refer to the part of the story you’re going to cover.
The second sentence should focus on the particular detail(s) you’re about to address.
Now make the point you want to make by analyzing how the specific text you’re referring to demonstrates your claim. This will take four (4) or five (5) sentences.
The first sentence should establish how the text serves as an example of the point being made.
The next sentence should elaborate on the previous one by pointing to additional detail or establishing how the text relates to other excerpts from the piece. The main thing here is to elaborate — either get into more detail, or tie the excerpt to other, similar examples.
The next sentence or two (2) should tackle some kind of counterargument. In other words, how might a reader try to disagree with your claim? Try to resist that imagined disagreement by first establishing what it could be and then briefly claiming why it’s incorrect. Pointing to yet more details of the excerpt is desirable here.
Finally, wrap up your point by indicating how this point might lead to the next related idea.
Each paragraph should be from eight (8), minimum, to ten (10), maximum sentences long. When you’re finished, submit your finished work here.


