Week 3:External Environment II

Learning Objectives

By the end of today’s session, you should be able to:

Understand the Five Forces Model

Distinguish between the firm and industry effects.

Discuss how competitive industry structures impact firm strategic decision-making.

2

A Few Definitions

Firm – organization that combines and transforms resources to obtain a profit.

Industry – a group of firms facing similar environmental conditions.

Industry Analyses – an in-depth analyses of threats and opportunities at the industry level.

Strategic Position – the strategic structuring that allows the firm operate.

Competition – an economic contest for profit between firms.

Competitive Advantage – an inherent and underlying advantage that gives the firm the potential for a profitability edge over its competitors.

3

Industry vs. Firm Effects

Firm performance is influenced by:

Industry effects – the underlying economic structure of the industry (e.g., exit & entry barriers).

Firm effects – the decisions, strategies and behaviors of firms/its leadership.

4

Industry vs. Firm EffectsRothaermel (2021)

5

Porter’s Five Forces Model

Defines competition broadly (at the industry level rather than direct competitors).

Profit and profit potential is conceptualized as a function of:

threat of entry.

power of suppliers.

power of buyers.

threat of substitutes.

rivalry among existing firms.

6

Porter’s Five Forces Model

The stronger the five forces – the lower the industry’s profit potential.

The weaker the five forces, the greater the industry’s profit potential.

The most strategically advantageous “move” for a firm is to minimize the exposure to “strong forces” and leverages the exposer to “weak forces.”

7

Porter’s Five Forces ModelPorter (2008)

8

The Threat of Entry

Is defined as the risk of potential competitors to enter the industry.

Higher threat of entry reduces the industry’s profit potential.

Higher threat of entry requires higher levels of spending in order to maintain consumer interest.

Higher threat of entry requires more strategic capacity (i.e., monitoring, evaluation, decision-making).

9

Barriers to Entry

Regulations.

Economies of scale.

High entry costs/capital.

Threat of retaliation.

Network effects.

Brand loyalty.

10

The Power of Suppliers

Is defined as the degree to which suppliers can bargain for favorable terms.

Powerful suppliers/limited supply competition typically reduces profit potential.

Limited supply competition reduces options and increases operational risk.

11

To Mitigate Supplier Power

Firms can:

Develop new supply relationships/networks.

Redesign products to improve supply options (i.e., to allow for substitute parts).

Minimize reliance on powerful suppliers.

Evaluate options to integrate (through mergers and acquisitions).

12

The Power of Buyers/Consumers

Is defined as the degree to which buyers can bargain for/have access to different pricing and quality options.

Strong buyer power forces firms to make pricing and quality concessions hence reducing profit potential.

Buyer power can evolve directly from buyers (i.e., few buyers) or from the nature of the industry (i.e., low levels of product differentiation.

13

Factors that Lead to High Buyers’ Power

Few (powerful) buyers.

Undifferentiated products.

There are low/no switching costs.

Buyer regulatory protections.

14

The Threat of Substitutes

Is defined as the degree to which buyers can access products outside the industry that would continue to meet needs.

The threat of substitutes is high when customers define a service broadly (i.e., financial services – professional investment vs. individual investment based on professional advice ).

The threat of substitutes is high when customers face low or no switching costs (i.e., tax preparation from human to an AI-based software).

15

Rivalry among Competitors

Is describes the intensity with which firms compete for/contest market share and profitability.

Higher forces (1 through 4) lower levels of profitability potential.

Intensity is a function of:

Industry structure.

Entry/exit barriers.

Growth prospects.

Strategic/fixed commitments/investments.

16

Rivalry: Industry Structures

The degree to which and industry is competitive is determined by the following considerations:

Number of competitors.

Size of competitors.

Firm pricing power.

Product/service type/differentiation.

Market protection/entry barriers.

17

Rivalry: Degrees of Competitiveness

Perfect competition.

Monopolistic competition.

Oligopoly.

Monopoly.

18

Rivalry: Industry Competitive StructuresRothaermel (2021)

19

Rivalry: Entry/Exit Barriers

The degree to which firms can enter or leave the industry determines the degree of rivalry.

Higher exit barriers make it more difficult to exit (hence reduce excess capacity) making rivalry more intense.

20

Rivalry: Growth Prospects

Growth (increase in demand) increases the market and dilutes levels of rivalry.

Industry centrality (the degree to which and industry becomes the based for economic development trends) increase growth prospects and hence current rivalry intensity.

Continued intense rivalry may reduce the overall growth prospects given that it may reduce incentives to entry.

21

Rivalry: Strategic/Fixed Commitments/Investments

The more committed a firm is to a given industry – the higher the level of rivalry.

The “longer-term” a firm’s strategy is – the higher the level of rivalry.

The larger the fixed/investment costs – the higher the level of rivalry.

22

Testimonials

Week3ExternalAnalysesII.pptx
We have updated our contact contact information. Text Us Or WhatsApp Us+1-(309) 295-6991