Nursing and the Law © Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock It’s Your Gavel… CHANCE OF SURVIVAL DIMINISHED On the afternoon of May 20, the patient, Mr. Ard, began feeling nauseated. He was in pain and had shortness of breath. Although his wife rang the call bell several times, it was not until sometime later that evening that someone responded and gave Ard medication for the nausea. The nausea continued to worsen. Mrs. Ard then noticed that her husband was having difficulty breathing. He was reeling from side to side in bed. Believing that her husband was dying, she continued to call for help. She estimated that she rang the call bell for 1.25 hours before anyone responded. A code was eventually called. Unfortunately, Mr. Ard did not survive the code. There was no documentation in the medical records for May 20, between 5:30 PM and 6:45 PM, that would indicate that any nurse or physician checked on Ard’s condition. This finding collaborated Mrs. Ard’s testimony regarding this time period. A wrongful death action was brought against the hospital, and the district court granted judgment for Mrs. Ard. The hospital appealed. Ms. Krebs, an expert in general nursing, stated that it should have been obvious to the nurses from the physicians’ progress notes that the patient was a high risk for aspiration. This problem was never addressed in the nurses’ care plan or in the nurses’ notes. On May 20, Ard’s assigned nurse was Ms. Florscheim. Krebs stated that Florscheim did not perform a full assessment of the patient’s respiratory and lung status. There was nothing in the record indicating that she completed such an evaluation after he vomited. Krebs also testified that a nurse did not conduct a swallowing assessment at any time. Although Florscheim testified that she checked on the patient around 6:00 PM on May 20, there was no documentation in the medical record. Ms. Farris, an expert witness for the defense, testified on cross-examination that if a patient was in the type of distress described by Mrs. Ard and no nurse checked on him for 1.25 hours, that would fall below the expected standard of care. WHAT IS YOUR VERDICT? To Be a Nurse: Swedish Hospital, Seattle, Washington • Nursing is the honor and privilege of caring for the needs of individuals in their time of need. The responsibility is one of growth to develop the mind, soul, and physical well-being of oneself as well as the one cared for. • In memory of all those patients that have enriched my life and blessed me with their spirit of living—while they are dying. • There are many things I love about being an RN, but as a Recovery Room nurse, my favorite, by far, is being able to tell a groggy but anxious patient, “It was benign.” • Excellence is about who we are, what we believe in, what we do with everyday of our lives. And in some ways we are a sum total of those who have loved us and those who we have given ourselves to. • I have been with a number of people/patients when they die and have stood in awe. Nursing encompasses the sublime and the dreaded. We are regularly expected to do the impossible. I feel honored to be in this profession. • To get well, I knew I had to accept the care and love that were given to me—when I did healing washed over me like water. • Through all of this I was never alone. • Thank you! • In the caring for one another, both are forever changed. • A friend takes your hand and touches your heart. • To all of you whose names were blurred by the pain and the drugs. • Don’t ever underestimate your role in getting patients back on their feet. —Swedish Hospital, Seattle, Washington, Unknown Authors Learning Objectives The reader, upon completion of this chapter, will be able to: • Describe how the scope of nursing practice continues to evolve. • Describe common categories of nursing staff. • Explain the process of obtaining nurse licensure. • Describe a variety of the legal risks nurses encounter. • Describe the ways in which a nurse is a patient advocate. This chapter provides an overview of nursing practice, nurse licensure, and various nursing specialties, as well as a review of cases focused on the legal risks of nurses. The cases presented highlight those areas in which nurses tend to be most vulnerable to lawsuits. 11.1 SCOPE OF PRACTICE The role of the nurse continues to evolve and expand due to a shortage of primary care physicians in rural and inner-city areas, ever-increasing specialization, improved technology, public demand, and expectations within the profession itself. A nurse who exceeds his or her scope of practice as defined by applicable statutes (e.g., nurse practice acts) can be found to have violated licensure provisions and thus be subject to disciplinary action. The following table describes several of the key historical events that have led to the continuing expansion of the roles and duties of nurses in patient care settings. The expanding scope of nursing practice is accompanied by increased ethical and legal risks. Nurses are at risk for inappropriate professional relationships due to the broadening scope of nursing practice amidst rapid societal changes and pressures. The complexities of professional nursing relationships have outpaced awareness of ethical considerations of boundary issues. In addition, because professional nursing is founded on a caring ethic and nurses become intimately involved in life experiences of clients and families, nurses may be at risk for confusion over boundaries and inappropriate relationships. Boundaries, which historically were unclear, are increasingly recognized as an issue for the profession. NOTEWORTHY EVENTS IN THE EXPANDING SCOPE OF NURSING PRACTICE 1901—New York began to organize for passage of nurse practice legislation. 1903—North Carolina enacted the first nurse registration act. 1905—The development of the hospital economics course at Teachers College, Columbia University, ushered in a new era in preparation of nurse leaders in America. This 1-year certificate course was extended to a 2-year post–basic training program in 1905. The commitment of key nursing leaders to advancing educational preparation for nurse faculty fostered the subsequent development of baccalaureate education in nursing during the first quarter of the 20th century.
Ch.12-LegalAspectsofHealtcare.docx
Hospital Departments and Allied Professionals © Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock It’s Your Gavel… DYING AT THE HOSPITAL’S DOOR … TROUBLING QUESTIONS While communications were breaking down among a child’s parent, a 9-1-1 dispatcher, and hospital personnel, the child’s condition was quickly deteriorating. Twelve hours later, the three-year-old girl was brain dead, and she expired three days later. Although there are several central issues involved in this story, the frustrating dialogue that took place is particularly important. The 9-1-1 dispatcher answers the phone: Dispatcher: 9-1-1; is this an emergency? Parent: Yes, it’s an emergency. I need an ambulance. I have a 3-year-old daughter that’s passed out on me. Dispatcher: OK. Where do you need the ambulance? Parent: I’m right in front of the emergency exit at Coral Springs Hospital. Dispatcher: You’re right in front of the emergency exit? Parent: Yes, that’s exactly where I am. And they won’t do a … thing in this place. The dispatcher phones the hospital emergency department: Dispatcher: There’s a guy that says he’s right outside your emergency exit. And he needs an ambulance. He says his 3-year-old daughter is passed out. Hospital: This is a guy who wants to be seen quicker. We’re busy—so he figured if he called 9-1-1 he’d be seen quicker. Dispatcher: Well, he’s saying he needs an ambulance right away. Is somebody going to go out there, or not? Hospital: There’s nothing we can do. The parents were offered an out-of-court settlement totaling $200,000. This tragedy might have been prevented if the patient had been screened and triaged by a person competent to determine the patient’s need for immediate care. Failure to assign triage responsibility to a competent individual can lead to lawsuits that involve not only the hospital, but also the supervisor who assigns responsibilities to unqualified staff members. WHAT IS YOUR VERDICT? __________ Miami Herald, April 16, 1995, by Ronnie Green. Copyright 1995 by Miami Herald. Reproduced with permission of Miami Herald in the format Textbook via Copyright Clearance Center. Learning Objectives The reader, upon completion of this chapter, will be able to: • Describe the wide variety of legal issues that occur in the emergency department setting. • Understand the purpose of the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act. • Describe a variety of negligent errors by various healthcare professionals that have applications to most caregivers. • Describe the purpose of certification and licensure, and the reasons for revocation of licenses. • Explain the importance of a multidisciplinary approach to patient care. This chapter presents an overview of selected departments and healthcare professions. Although it describes a variety of legal issues, there is no intensive review of any specific department or profession. Many of the cases presented in this chapter could have been discussed in more than one chapter; they were placed here to illustrate that no healthcare profession is exempt from the long arm of the legal system. Healthcare professionals are held to the prevailing standard of care required in their profession, which includes proper assessments, reassessments, diagnosis, treatment, and follow-up care. 12.1 EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT Emergency departments, see , are high-risk areas that tend to be a main source of lawsuits for hospitals. Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study revealed that the hospital emergency department is “a real hot spot” for negligence. In this study, 70% of adverse events occurring in the emergency department were because of negligence. Hospital emergency departments, which are heavily used by patients as primary care clinics, are a major source of adverse events because of poor follow-up care. Suits that end up in a courtroom are small in number compared with the out-of-court settlements. $216.7 Million Medical Malpractice Verdict in Florida A Florida jury yesterday awarded a whopping $100.1 million in punitive damages to a Tampa man who was left brain-damaged and disabled after hospital emergency room doctors misdiagnosed stroke symptoms for a headache. Including compensatory damages of $116.7 million, the jury awarded Allan Navarro $216.7 million. The verdict is the third largest U.S. medical malpractice award ever, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. —Peter Lattman, The Wall Street Journal, October 4, 2006 Both federal and state regulations, as well as standards set by accrediting agencies, may be considered by the courts to establish the duty of hospital emergency departments to provide emergency care to those who present themselves with the need for such care. Hospitals, for example, under the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) are required to first provide stabilizing treatment and transfer to an appropriate healthcare facility when necessary. © Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock Figure 12-1 The courts recognize a general duty to care for all patients presenting themselves to hospital emergency departments. Not only must hospitals accept, treat, and transfer emergency department patients if such is necessary for the patients’ well-being, but they also must adhere to the standards of care they have set for themselves, as well as to national standards. Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act In 1986, Congress passed the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA), which forbids Medicare-participating hospitals from “dumping” patients out of emergency departments. The act provides that:
2021FormatoPlandeCuidado.docx
UNIVERSIDAD INTERAMERICANA DE PUERTO RICO RECINTO DE GUAYAMA DEPARTAMENTO DE CIENCIAS DE LA SALUD PROGRAMA DE ENFERMERÍA PLAN DE CUIDADO SALUD MENTAL ESTUDIANTE: _____________________________________________SECCIÓN: ________________FECHA: ____________________ PROFESOR: ______________________________________________ CÓDIGO Y NOMBRE DEL CURSO: ______________________________ A. DATOS DEL PACIENTE: Entrega Instrumento
Legal Concerns for Medical Administration
Evaluate why prescribing, control, and administration of medications is a major area of legal concern for health care providers. What is the impact of medication errors to the patient and the health care provider? Discuss ways doctors make mistakes in
eretyhu
Carbon Dioxide LabThis weeks readings included a discussion surrounding the ongoing debate of whether or not to add carbon dioxide to the list of air pollutants regulated by the EPA (p. 546). Regardless of current policy, research shows that
Malpractice Suites
Discuss how physician malpractice suits can be decreased. How can a doctor be sued for malpractice? What current practices do doctors perform in order to avoid law suits? What are the impacts of these practices? How can one check for
Cognitive Psychology
4 pg (expository) Due Sunday April 10th Please follow the rubric to provide the best quality work Introduction and conclusion is mandatory APA format 7th edition Provide correct citations and references Plagiarism free, turn it I’m report, A+ work,
IANS.docx
Read Case Study 14-23 "Ian's Place" (The REA Model and E-R Diagrams) on page 457 in Core Concepts of Accounting Information Systems. Write a 45- to 175-word response to question 1. Complete the items identified for questions 2 and 3. NOTE: For question 2 (E-R Diagram), use
TestDesignandItemDevelopment.docx
Imagine that you are the lead teacher for this unit of study and must modify materials and instruction to suit the needs of your learners. �Create a 4 question quiz to assess the skills targeted by this unit of
assignment_4Nursing301rev21jan211.doc
Nursing 301 Assignment : Nursing practice paper (medication error) Guidelines for nursing practice paper: Write a paper addressing a current, significant problem observed in your clinical nursing practice (or previous student clinical experiences) that interferes with the provision of competent