ASSIGNMENT
There is a phenomenon of “Split Brain”, a condition in which the connection between the two brain hemispheres is severed, as a last resort surgery to prevent severe epileptic seizures.
Similarly, the frontal lobes and portions of the limbic system are important in the control of emotions; surgery that severs the connections to and from these portions of the brain or surgery that removes them (partially or entirely) can have a profound effect on behavior. Similarly, electrically stimulating these portions of the brain can have a significant effect on behavior.
Questions:
- Under what circumstances (if any) do you think psychosurgery or electrical stimulation of people’s brains might be warranted?
- Should those with a chronic history of violent criminal offenses have the option of being treated with psychosurgery or electrical brain stimulation for a reduced sentence or as an alternative to the death penalty?
- What potential ethical concerns can you think of regarding sentence reduction?
- Racial, ethnic, social justice concerns
- Power differential between prisoner and medical staff
- Informed consent
Please justify your answers by using the concepts from your textbook (and other scientific resources).


